Latest News from Positive Action in Housing

URGENT – BREAKING NEWS: MELTEM AVCIL – REMOVAL BY PRIVATE JET IMMINENT

November 21, 2007 · 56 Comments

UPDATE: 21ST November 2007 – 5pm
PLEASE NOTE THAT THE GERMAN AUTHORITIES HAVE CONFIRMED THEY EXPECT MELTEM AVCIL AND HER MOTHER IN DUSSELDORF TOMORROW THURSDAY 22 NOVEMBER AT 10:00 HRS. THE UK AUTHORITIES HAVE NOT GIVEN TIME OR PLACE OF THE FLIGHT DEPARTURE.
THE FAMILY IS AT BEDFORD HOSPITAL, UNDER CLOSE GUARD.
THE NATIONAL UNION OF TEACHERS HAS NOW GIVEN THEIR FULL BACKING TO MELTEM AVCIL’S BID TO REMAIN IN THE UK.

Meltem
Meltems Birthday CardInside Meltems Card

We have just been informed that government authorization has been granted to Home Office officials to charter a private jet to remove 14 year old Hall Cross Lower pupil, Meltem Avcil, and her mother, either today or first thing tomorrow. We have been informed that removal is IMMINENT and “use of force” has been authorized.

Meltem Avcil, whose 14th birthday is today, had been assessed by doctors from Medical Justice yesterday. There was concern about Meltem’s psychological state, as a result of being incarcerated for three months at Yarlswood Detention Centre, after being dawn raided by an immigration snatch squad at their flat in Doncaster, their home for the past six years. Doctors requested she be transferred to Bedford hospital for assessment.

Until literally minutes ago, Meltem’s supporters believed she had been transferred to Bedford hospital along with her mother. Unfortunately, our sources have informed us that it was “extremely worrying” that Meltem was being taken from Yarls Wood WITH her mother.

What is most worrying of all is that the Children’s Commissioner has taken up Meltem’s case and Dianne Abbott MP raised her case in the House of Commons yesterday. Meltem’s case was also highlighted in today’s Independent newspaper.

Meltem’s mobile phone has been cut off. During her time at Yarls Wood she says she was denied access to newspaper coverage of her case. The Home Office has cut off all communication with Meltem’s lawyers, despite counsel standing by to carry out a judicial review of her case.

We are concerned that Meltem’s school, Hall Cross Lower, responded to Meltem’s predicament by saying they “wish her the best of luck for the future” . We are also concerned that the National Union of Teachers, where protests were held today in Doncaster, have issued no statement on the treatment of Meltem Avcil.

PLEASE ACT NOW – email and copy.

Write directly to Prime Minister Gordon Brown to protest at the removal of Meltem Avcil. Email browng@parliament.uk. Write also to the Home Secretary homesecretary.submissions@homeoffice.gsi.gov.uk .

Please copy your mail to: robina@paih.org and adrian.matthews@11million.org.uk (email for Sir Al Aynsley-Green, children’s commissioner)

********************************************************

FOR REFERENCE – SEE BELOW ARTICLES OF INTEREST:

Meltem Avcil’s Testimony, the Article in today’s independent about Meltems case. Please act now.
Thursday 15 November 2007
Meltem Avcil’s Testimony

At 3.25 am, some officers came into the small room I share with my mother. Ten minutes later, they took us down to the reception.

At 3.45 am, five escorts, one woman and four men arrived; the woman searched our bodies in front of the waiting men. Then, one of the men escorts, came up to me, he was talking loudly, looking with a mean face, and said:

“If you refuse to go on the plane we will handcuff both of you and tie your legs. Okay?”

They took us to a black van, two escorts next to me, one next to my mum, the other two in the front. They chatted by themselves during the journey. I could hear my mum crying very quietly. I wasn’t crying. The lady escort asked me what year at school I am in, it was a strange question because I was locked up, not in school. I said

‘Year 9’. Then, she said,

“You must be looking forward to your GCSEs”.

I didn’t answer, but my tears came I couldn’t help it so I looked out the window. Then she said,

“well, obviously not.”.

They started chatting amongst themselves. Then that male escort said to me:

“You know if you refuse to go on the plane, I will handcuff your mum and tie her feet.”

I did not answer, I didn’t like him saying things about my mum. They went quiet, and he told the escorts to talk to me. I said to the lady,

“is that man your manager?

She said:

“yes”.

After a while the escorts fell asleep, I looked out of the window, but it was dark. I was thinking what were my friends doing, would I see my school again. I was saying to myself why do I have to be here when my friends are outside, why do I have to go into a country I don’t know. I felt angry with everyone.

Then they woke up and started chatting again, it became daylight, they stopped somewhere. The manager went for a cigarette, we waited in the van, he got back in, and they kept driving.

We arrived at Heathrow, the manager took my mother through security, but not normal security like other passengers, he came back with my mum to the van, he had another cigarette. Another man took me through security. When he brought me back, the manager was waiting, then he said to me very loudly,

“You know if u refuse to go on the plane, we’ll put handcuffs on you and tie your feet, tell your mum what I said.”

I told my mum. They drove us right next to the plane, we stopped, and the manager said to me that,

“Germany faxed a letter through saying that they are going to look at your asylum again, then you might be successful, and get your status and Leave to Remain in Germany, and come back to this country.”

And then, obviously, I didn’t believe that, and I told this to my mum, and she didn’t believe it either.

Next to the plane, the manager and another male escort, they took my mum out, and my mum started crying more and tried not to go up the steps. The manager went on top of my mother, held her legs down, and went to handcuff her, but the handcuffs hit my mothers face badly, and she was bruised and cut. He handcuffed her, and dragged her off the [tarmac] and up the plane steps to the very back of the plane. I started crying, I was scared. Two escorts held me by the hands but I kept saying ‘let me go’ but one of the escorts pinched my hands to make me go. And then they put me in the plane, I was crying.

Passengers were looking at us. The manager sat with my mother on one side, she kept crying, he kept telling her “shut up, shut up”. Two or three passengers looked a bit worried, but the ones in front of us just kept reading their newspapers as if we were invisible, but my mother was crying. They sat me between two escorts who kept squeezing my hand very hard like to break my fingers. I kept crying and saying,

“I want to speak to the pilot”.

They closed the plane doors. I could not stop crying, and then the two escorts kept squeezing my hand hard.

Then the pilot came. He told my mum “SHUT UP”.

He never asked what the matter was. Do you know, the manager he kept squeezing my mums hand with the handcuffs on, i could see he was hurting her, I felt sick. I said to the manager

“stop hurting my mum”,

and the woman escort told me, it wasn’t hurting, but she kept squeezing my hand as well.

A teenage passenger started taking mobile phone pictures. The plane moved a bit, then the pilot said:

“We are sorry for the disturbance, the deportees should be off loaded”.

Then the pilot came to the back of the plane, he looking straight at me, and said to the air-hostess,

“bring the steps”.

We went down, and went in the van. They put us in the van quickly, they kept staring at us angrily, one of the men kept saying to me,

“you’re going back to Yarlswood, are you happy now?”

We drove for hours, they stopped a couple of times for cigarette breaks and burgers for themselves. One of them asked us if we wanted one, but we said no. We got back to yarls wood at 3.30pm. ENDS

Categories: Appeal · Deportation · Detention · against dawn raids · asylum decisions · asylum seekers · attacks on asylum seekers · dawn raids · destitution · ethnic minority communities

56 responses so far ↓

  • LYNN KROPP // November 21, 2007 at 3:16 pm | Reply

    To: browng@parliament.uk

    WHERE IS YOUR COMPASSION?

    LYNN KROPP
    DOMINIC THIERRY

  • Emily Cross // November 21, 2007 at 3:17 pm | Reply

    Dear Gordon Brown,
    I am writing out of deep concern that government authorization has been granted to Home Office officials to charter a private jet to remove 14 year old Hall Cross Lower pupil, Meltem Avcil, and her mother, either today or first thing tomorrow, and “use of force” has been authorized.
    Meltem Avcil, whose 14th birthday is today, had been assessed by doctors from Medical Justice yesterday. There was concern about Meltem’s psychological state, as a result of being incarcerated for three months at Yarlswood Detention Centre, after being dawn raided by an immigration snatch squad at their flat in Doncaster, their home for the past six years. Doctors requested she be transferred to Bedford hospital for assessment.
    Until literally minutes ago, Meltem’s supporters believed she had been transferred to Bedford hospital along with her mother.
    What is most worrying of all is that the Children’s Commissioner has taken up Meltem’s case and Dianne Abbott MP raised her case in the House of Commons yesterday. Meltem’s case was also highlighted in today’s Independent newspaper.
    Meltem’s mobile phone has been cut off. During her time at Yarls Wood she says she was denied access to newspaper coverage of her case. The Home Office has cut off all communication with Meltem’s lawyers, despite counsel standing by to carry out a judicial review of her case.
    Please act now to stop Meltem Avcil and her mother from being deported.
    Thank you,
    Emily Cross

  • David Ingleby // November 21, 2007 at 3:18 pm | Reply

    Dear Home Secretary,
    As a Briton living abroad I am appalled by the descriptions of the detention and forced removal of Meltem Avcil and her mother. I deplore the contempt for human rights, and especially for the rights of children, which speaks out of these actions. For the sake of Britain’s reputation as a civilised country, I urge you to conduct an urgent review of the way immigration policies are being implemented, starting with the behaviour of the personnel employed to carry out these deportations.
    Yours sincerely,
    David Ingleby

  • Ryan Mackie // November 21, 2007 at 3:19 pm | Reply

    Dear Home Secretary
    Having read the account from Meltem Avcil of the attempted forced removal of her and her mother on a BA flight to Germany (see below) I was utterly disgusted. I urge you, as a mother, to read it for yourself. I am further dismayed to read that the UK government is now preparing to charter a private plane.
    I ask you to urgently reconsider this decision.
    Yours sincerely
    Ryan Mackie

  • Louisa Parker // November 21, 2007 at 3:19 pm | Reply

    Dear Gordon Brown
    I am emailing to protest against the removal of schoolgirl Meltern Avcil, with whom I am sure you must be familiar. I have read the child’s account of her treatment, as well as the article in the Independent, and am horrified that a young person and her mother could be treated in this way. I feel that immigration issues are getting out of control and that refugees and asylum seekers in the UK are denied their basic human rights. I urge you to see the reality of what is happening and make it a priority to treat such people in a humane manner. This is the 21st century – these are real people with feelings – surely a child deserves the right to stay in the country she has lived in for the past few years and not be treated as a criminal? She has done nothing wrong.
    Yours in hope,
    Louisa Parker

  • Jim Taggart // November 21, 2007 at 3:22 pm | Reply

    Dear Gordon Brown,
    I have just recieved the e-mail copied below. The forcible removal of teenage school children, settled in this counrty, does no good for them or their education. I urge you to put a stop to the barbaric forcible removal of Meltem Avicil, I would also point out that for a Labour government to allow such cruel proceedures does no good for the standing of the Labour party.
    Jim Taggart

  • Tarin Brokenshire // November 21, 2007 at 3:22 pm | Reply

    Dear Jacqui Smith,
    I am horrified to learn that the BIA is planning to remove Meltem Avcil and her mother from this country by private charter jet in spite of medical advice to the contrary. Will you please take immediate action to stop this. I won’t go into into any detail on their case – I’m sure you have the information available but I have been following their story for some weeks now and am familiar with their situation.
    Yours sincerely,
    Tarin Brokenshire

  • Heather Alari // November 21, 2007 at 3:26 pm | Reply

    Dear Mr Brown
    I would urge you to take action re Meltem Avcil and her mother, and by this, I mean not to return them to Germany or Turkey, and certainly not back into a detention centre in this country or any other. I consider the asylum system in the UK to be inhumane and shameful in many respects, especially with regard to asylum seekers who have fled their countries of origin because of human rights abuses. No children or families should be detained in these `private enterprise’ detention centres and I would ask you to read the email I received from Robina Quereshi on this matter.
    Meltem and her mother are in need of relevant and compassionate support, not further harrassment, and I consider all involved should feel utterly ashamed – be this on their consciences.
    Your sincerely
    Heather Alari
    Dunfermline.

  • Tarin Brokenshire // November 21, 2007 at 3:28 pm | Reply

    Dear Prime MInister,
    I am horrified to learn that the BIA is planning to remove Meltem Avcil and her mother from this country by private charter jet in spite of medical advice to the contrary. Will you please take immediate action to stop this. I won’t go into into any detail on their case – I’m sure you have the information available but I have been following their story for some weeks now and am familiar with their situation.
    Yours sincerely,
    Tarin Brokenshire

  • Rosemary Galli // November 21, 2007 at 3:28 pm | Reply

    The Right Honourable Gordon Brown, Prime Minister

    Houses of Parliament

    Westminister

    Wednesday, 21 November 2007

    Dear Mr. Brown,
    While I realize your commitment to keep the UK safe from terrorism and mass immigration, I keep wondering if it is necessary to treat asylum-seekers, particularly children, as though they are criminals. I have written to your Home Secretary, Jacqui Smith, about this particular case but seemingly to no avail. The UK is becoming known as being particularly uncaring in regard to its own children as recent reports have shown and highlighted by the Children’s Commissioner. Is it not about time to pay attention to this and to the way children in the asylum system are treated?
    The reports in the Independent today are very revealing and I am attaching them below. Please, could you not exercise your prerogative to be compassionate in this situation?
    Yours truly,
    Rosemary Galli

  • Jeni Williams // November 21, 2007 at 3:36 pm | Reply

    Dear Gordon Brown and Jacqui Smith,
    I wish to protest vigorously and with total outrage at the appalling waste of resources (over £800 per person per week just for detention, airline tickets, escorts etc) allocated to the forced removal of a Turkish Kurdish girl and her mother from the UK. Thiis at a time when Turkey is stepping up attacks on Iraqi Kurdistan and increasing pressure on Kurdish dissidents within the country. I cannot believe what I read -that there is authorisation to charter a private jet. This seems inexplocable to me, even vindictive. Surely the UK government has better things to do with its resources than this. I am shocled and appalled that a girl who has been driven to self-harm should, against all decency, be kept locked up like a criminal for three months which her traumatised mother and then, after assessment by medical justice and a recommendation that she should be sent to hospital, forcibly removed with ‘authorised’ force. Just what kind of threat does a girl who is only 14 today offer to the state of Britain today. Criminals walk free from prison because of overcrowding, resources are slashed for old people because of funding crisis – and we waste money like this. I am utterly shocked and outraged at this barbaric behaviour and feel it a massive attack on the tenets of freedom and democracy that should characterise my country of birth.
    How a country treats its vulnerable is a measure of its civilisation. The UK does not fare well is tarnished by this petty aggression meted out to a damaged woman and her child. The waste, the viciousness, the violence of the treatment is appalling.
    I ask you to intervene in this sordid, grubby little horror story and prevent a genuine tragedy from occuring.
    Regards,
    Jeni Williams

  • Catrin Evans // November 21, 2007 at 3:38 pm | Reply

    To The Prime Minister and Home Secretary,
    I am writing to you to demand that you stop the removal of Meltem Avcil and her mother. The way that these two women have been treated by the British system is a disgrace and the cruelty that they have endured must be put to an end now.
    These two women must not be deported and they should be released from detention immediately.
    Catrin Evans

  • Iain Radcliffe // November 21, 2007 at 3:39 pm | Reply

    Dear Prime Minister,

    I am writing to you to protest against the forced deportation of 14-year-old Doncaster schoolgirl Meltem Avcil and her mother Cennet who are currently incarcerated at Yarlswood Detention Centre.

    Meltem, whose 14th birthday is today, had been assessed by doctors from Medical Justice yesterday. There was concern about Meltem’s psychological state, as a result of being incarcerated for three months at Yarlswood Detention Centre, after being dawn raided by an immigration snatch squad at their flat in Doncaster, their home for the past six years. Doctors requested she be transferred to Bedford hospital for assessment.

    Meltem has been living in Doncaster since 2001. Her schoolteachers at Hall Cross Lower School, Doncaster, describe her as a model student. She speaks with an English accent, speaks perfect English, her dreams and aspirations are essentially English, and the only place she knows as her true home is with friends, neighbours, school and community in Doncaster, England. For almost three months she and her mother have been in Yarlswood, and Meltem has reportedly begun self-harming recently amid fears for her psychological wellbeing.

    Meltem and her mother, Cennet, fear removal to Germany, a country they have absolutely no connection with, and from there to Turkey, a country they fled in 2001 because they were persecuted as Kurds.

    The family have clear human rights grounds for them to remain in the UK under a family amnesty and to not be removed to Germany:
    * She has been in school in the UK for SIX years
    * Mrs Avcil and her daughter have NEVER absconded or disobeyed ANY UK immigration rules
    * Both mother and child have been detained like criminals for almost THREE months
    * She has had NO schooling since being incarcerated
    * Her mental and psychological state has deteriorated, from being a normal, healthy bubbly teenager to a scared, depressed, lonely young girl, turning to self harm
    * Their lawyer is still pursuing legal routes to help them remain in this country
    I believe that the trauma that the UK government has put Meltem Avcil through will haunt her for the rest of her life, and that it is in the best interests of this child to be returned to her home in Doncaster, the familiarity of her school, friends and teachers, and to have access within this supportive environment to psychiatrists to assist her in returning to her former happy self.
    I therefore respectfully urge the Government not to carry out the forced removal of this family.
    Yours sincerely,
    Iain Radcliffe

  • Jack Anderson // November 21, 2007 at 3:40 pm | Reply

    Dear Mr Brown,
    Today is Meltem Avcil’s 14th birthday, yet she is spending it in constant fear – having just had a near escape from being deported from England (which has been her home for over 6 years) to Germany (a country which she barely knows and from which it is likely she will be deported on to Turkey where she and her mother face persecution) she is today facing “imminent” deportation. Meltem has lived in Yarl’s Wood detention centre for months, having been taken away from her home in Doncaster where she has many friends and does well in school. Her experiences at the hands of the UK immigration system have left her severely traumatised, and she recently began to self-harm. The solution to this is not to remove her to an unfamiliar country where her future is uncertain, but to allow her to regain some kind of normality in her life – at home in Doncaster.
    PLEASE use your power to stop her removal immediately.
    Yours sincerely,
    Jack Anderson

  • Penny Waterhouse // November 21, 2007 at 3:41 pm | Reply

    Dear Jacqui Smith,
    You need to know that I do not support the policy and actions of your Goverment, that will – unless you take immediate action now – lead to the forceable removal of Meltem Avcil.
    Meltem is only 14 years old. She is no threat to this country. She has lived peaceably and productively in this country for many years. Surely we have the heart and generousity to let her continue to do so.
    Doctors have now requested she be transferred to Bedford hospital because of her state of health – caused by the trauma created by people acting under your Government’s instruction. But instead you have chartered a private jet and sanctioned use of force: against a 14 year old traumatised girl?
    Is this what you are ready to do in your name? Would you be ready to do this to your own daughter?
    You shame me with your action and inaction.
    Penny Waterhouse
    LONDON

  • Emma Crawshaw // November 21, 2007 at 3:42 pm | Reply

    Dear Home Secretary and Prime Minister
    Please act to end the shameful treatment of Meltem Acvil and her mother. They have lived in the UK for 6 years and has developed roots in their community in Doncaster. Both are is facing forced removal to Turkey, where as a Kurd, they face a demonstrable and very serious risk of persecution and harm.
    Meltem Avcil, whose 14th birthday is today, had been assessed by doctors from Medical Justice yesterday. There was concern about Meltem’s psychological state, as a result of being incarcerated for three months at Yarlswood Detention Centre, after being dawn raided by an immigration snatch squad at their flat in Doncaster, their home for the past six years. Doctors requested she be transferred to Bedford hospital for assessment.
    As 400,000 UK residents are emigrating annually, surely we do not need to treat innocent children in this manner which has drawn condemnation from all 3 Children’s Rights Commissioners and many thousands of voters across the UK.
    Yours sincerely
    Emma Crawshaw
    EDINBURGH

  • Satnam Ner // November 21, 2007 at 3:43 pm | Reply

    Dear Home Secretary,
    FORCED REMOVAL OF MRS CENNET AVCIL & MELTEM AVCIL I am writing to you about 13 year old Doncaster schoolgirl Meltem Avcil and her mother Cennet who are currently incarcerated at Yarlswood Detention Centre, and due to be removed by private jet.
    Meltem has been living in Doncaster, England for the past six years, since 2001. Her schoolteachers at Hall Cross Lower School, Doncaster, describe her as a ‘No.1 student’. She speaks with an English accent, speaks perfect English, her dreams and aspirations are essentially English, and the only country she knows as her home in the true sense of the word is Doncaster, England where her friends, neighbours, school and community remains. Her 14th birthday is on November 21. For almost three months she and her mother have been in Yarlswood, and Meltem has recently begun self harming amid fears for her psychological well-being.
    Meltem and her mother, Cennet, fear removal to Germany, a country they have absolutely no connection with, and from there to Turkey, a country they fled in 2001 because they were persecuted as Kurds.
    The family has lived in the UK for over six years and have clear human rights grounds for them to remain in the UK under a family amnesty and to not be removed to Germany:
    * Meltem Avcil is 13 years old and about to turn 14 tomorrow.
    * She has been in school in the UK for SIX years
    * Mrs Avcil and her daughter have NEVER absconded or disobeyed ANY UK immigration rules
    * Both mother and child have been detained like criminals for almost THREE months
    * She has had NO schooling since being incarcerated
    * Her mental and psychological state has deteriorated, from being a normal, healthy bubbly teenager to a scared, depressed, lonely young girl, turning to self harm (She began cutting herself a few days ago)
    * Their lawyer is still pursuing legal routes to help them remain in this country
    The facts of Meltem’s case are very similar to that of the AY family (who, as home secretary you should be familiar with), where the German government gave status to the family on humanitarian grounds, after psychiatric reports showed the children had been psychologically traumatised during their incarceration in the United Kingdom.
    I believe that the trauma that the UK government has put Meltem Avcil through will haunt her for the rest of her life, and that it is in the best interests of this child to be returned to her home in Doncaster, the familiarity of her school, friends and teachers, and to have access within this comfort zone to psychiatrists to assist her in returning to her former happy self.
    I therefore respectfully urge you, on behalf of the campaign, not to carry out the forced removal of this family. No doubt you will hear from some of the campaign’s fellow supporters too.
    I look forward to hearing from you at your earliest convenience.
    Yours sincerely,
    Satnam Ner
    FIFE

  • Jawaid // November 21, 2007 at 3:44 pm | Reply

    To whom it may concern
    I would like to address my bitter disappointment and shock at the way our government is dealing with Meltem. We have more pressing issues that need urgent attention, yet you have time to remove an innocent young girl from this country. I can understand the decision for offenders or criminals but what has Meltem done to deserve this. She has been in this country for 6 years or so now, she has become accustomed to this way of life.
    Where is the sanity and justice and the outright human rights? This is really appalling – the information below is just disgusting regarding Meltem’s treatment.
    My plea Prime Minister and Home Secretary is to please keep Meltem here in the UK – I hope you will act on this from a leadership point of view and a man concerned.
    Thanking you
    Jawaid
    GLASGOW

  • Andy McNeill // November 21, 2007 at 3:46 pm | Reply

    Hello,
    I am looking to find out what crime is commited by a 14year old girl so that she is subject to the detention and psycholgical tactics employed in her forced removal. I am looking to find the justification and need for the use of force against a minor as an instrument of coercion for her family.
    I cant find any reasoning for this activity to be carried out on this young girls family let alone the young girl in question. There rae countless pieces of legislation to protect young people from violence, abuse, torture and their is the accompanying rhetoric form the government.
    I beleive that these actions are morally and socially wrong in any context against a minor.
    Andy McNeill

  • Amy Sutton // November 21, 2007 at 3:47 pm | Reply

    Dear Mr Brown and Ms Smith
    I call on you to have some humanity and stop the deportation of Meltem Avcil and her mother from Yarlswood detention centre which her supporters state is now imminent by private jet. You are breaking the UK’s commitments to international law and as a citizen of this country I call on you to abide by it.
    I, and many ,many others like me, are not convinced by the propoganda you churn out and encourage in the British media. We know what is going on, and we want it stopped. You make me ashamed to be British.
    I would like a reply by return outlining what you are doing in Meltem Avcil and her mother’s case to respect their human rights and their right to humanitarian protection under the 1951 Refugee Convention. If you cannot provide this, please tell me how on earth you justify your behaviour.
    Yours sincerely
    Amy Sutton
    LONDON

  • Penny Earle // November 21, 2007 at 3:47 pm | Reply

    Dear Mr Brown
    In the name of humanity, let these two innocent women stay. I have seen the attitude to Kurds in Turkey. It is not pleasant and, for sure, these two women would end up in jail or worse.
    Yours sincerely
    Penny Earle

  • Alistair Hulett // November 21, 2007 at 3:48 pm | Reply

    Dear Sir/Madam,
    I am writing to urgently and strongly request that the forced removal of Meltem Avcil be cancelled immediately. This is not acceptable behavior on the part of the authorities and I fully support the efforts of civil rights campaigners and refugee support groups to have the decision reversed in Meltem’s favour.
    Your faithfully
    Alistair Hulett
    GLASGOW

  • Dr Colin Swatridge // November 21, 2007 at 3:54 pm | Reply

    Dear Prime Minister

    Along with thousands of others, I have been following the story of the deportation of Cennet and Meltem Avcil. I lecture at a Hungarian university, but nowhere is far from information now, of a sort that brings a civilised country into disrepute.

    I know well why it is that the Home Office is laying such stress on the deportation of those seeking asylum whose applications have been refused; but the most hard-nosed of us must be appalled by the treatment of these two persons, a mother and her 14-year old daughter, and the uncertainty in which they have been condemned to live in recent months.

    They are not being treated humanely, and in a way that I can defend, when I lecture on civilisation to Hungarian university students.

    I reqest that you use your best efforts to resolve this case in the only way that common humanity would decree, and that is to allow Meltem to return to school, and her mother to return to the community of which she has become a part. We must not act in ways that we would disparage in those countries from which asylum seekers flee.

    Yours faithfully
    Dr Colin Swatridge
    Miskolc University, Hungary.

  • Rev. David A. Collins // November 21, 2007 at 3:57 pm | Reply

    Dear Gordon,
    I was extremely concerned to read in today’s Independent of the plight of Meltem Avcil and her mother. I have followed the details of this case for some time now and am apalled at the way this 14 year old has been treated, regardless of the rights and wrongs of her case as an asylum seeker. As you will know Meltem’s case has been taken up by Sir Al Aynsley-Green, the Children’s Commissioner, and Dianne Abbott MP raised her case in the House of Commons yesterday. It cannot be morally right to treat a child in the way that Meltem has been treated over the past months, and I therefore urge you to act now to prevent her forced removal.

    Yours sincerely,
    Rev. David A. Collins

    The Church of Scotland,
    Auchterhouse, Murroes & Tealing

  • Rachel Pena // November 21, 2007 at 3:58 pm | Reply

    Dear Mr Brown,
    I would like to express my support for Meltem Avcil and her mother Cennet. Whatever the details of their case, I feel strongly that it is utterly wrong for people, and in particular children, to be incarcerated and forcibly removed. From what I understand, Meltem is not receiving and education, and despite concerns for her mental health, an attempt was made to remove her and her mother from the UK. I object to the manner of these removals, with families being taken from their homes or detention centre in the middle of the night and treated at best roughly and with force.
    I would like to see you intervene in this case, and also tackle this whole issue. It is wrong for a country like the UK to be detaining children and families and treating them so appallingly.
    Yours sincerely,
    Rachel Pena
    Edinburgh

  • Malcolm Burns // November 21, 2007 at 3:59 pm | Reply

    Dear Prime Minister Brown and Home Secretary Smith
    CENNET AND MELTEM AVCIL – REQUEST TO STOP FORCED DEPORTATION
    This is an urgent matter. I refer to the forced removal of Cennet Avcil and her 13 year old daughter Meltem planned by the UK immigration authorities to Germany.
    I understand that a private plane has been chartered. This is after the Avcil family could not be transported by BA last week because of the distress caused to the family, to passengers and to crew. I also understand that the “use of force” has been authorised.
    This family has been incarcerated in Britain having committed no crime but fleeing from persecution in Turkey due to their being Kurdish. If they are deported to Germany it is likely that they will be returned to Turkey where they fear for their lives. That cannot be right.
    Like many Scots and other British people, I am concerned about forced deportation of people who really ought to be given help by what we should be able to regard as our civilised society.
    I cannot see what is served by using force against vulnerable people like these, Meltem Avcil is a child.
    Please act urgently in all our best interests and revoke this deportation so that these people can have a safe future and our country’s reputation is not further diminished by these cruel acts.
    I look forward to you reply.
    Malcolm Burns
    GLASGOW

  • Dr Fraser Smith. // November 21, 2007 at 4:00 pm | Reply

    Dear Sir/Madam,
    By what right are you complicit in the forced removal of a 14 year old girl and her mother from this country?
    People who have spent six years in this country and one of which is apparently suffering serious mental health problems due to being dawn raided and incarcerated.
    By what right?
    If you are religious, then think of Jesus, Buddha and so on – who would support you in your actions?
    But you will have to live with them.
    Hoping you change your mind,
    Dr Fraser Smith.

  • Mike Arnott // November 21, 2007 at 4:02 pm | Reply

    Dear Prime Minister,
    MELTEM AVCIL – REMOVAL BY PRIVATE JET IMMINENT
    We have just been informed that government authorisation has been granted to Home Office officials to charter a private jet to remove 14 year Doncaster Hall Cross Lower School pupil, Meltem Avcil, and her mother, either today or first thing tomorrow. We have been informed that removal to Germany is IMMINENT and “use of force” has been authorised.
    Meltem Avcil, whose 14th birthday is today, had been assessed by doctors from Medical Justice yesterday. There was concern about Meltem’s psychological state, as a result of being incarcerated for three months at Yarlswood Detention Centre, after being dawn raided by an immigration snatch squad at their flat in Doncaster, their home for the past six years. Doctors requested she be transferred to Bedford hospital for assessment.
    Until literally minutes ago, Meltem’s supporters believed she had been transferred to Bedford hospital along with her mother. Unfortunately, sources have informed us that it was “extremely worrying” that Meltem was being taken from Yarls Wood with her mother.
    The Children’s Commissioner has taken up Meltem’s case and Dianne Abbott MP raised her case in the House of Commons yesterday. Her case was also highlighted in today’s Independent newspaper.
    Meltem’s mobile phone has been cut off. During her time at Yarls Wood she says she was denied access to newspaper coverage of her case. The Home Office has cut off all communication with Meltem’s lawyers, despite counsel standing by to carry out a judicial review of her case.
    We would be grateful if you could personally intervene with immediate effect, to end the mental anguish which your Government is inflicting on a teenage girl and her mother. This is not what we expect from a Government under your leadership. We trust your reaction to this e-mail will not disappoint.
    Yours in anticipation,
    Mike Arnott
    Secretary, Dundee TUC

  • ALEXANDRA MACRAE // November 21, 2007 at 4:04 pm | Reply

    I AM VERY SORRY TO NOTE THAT WISER AND MORE HUMANE COUNSELS HAVE NOT PREVAILED AND THAT YOU ARE PROCEEDING WITH THE DEPORTATION OF THIS YOUNG SCHOOL GIRL BECAUSE HER STAY IN THIS COUNTRY IS ALLEGEDLY IN CONTRAVENTION OF THE IMMIGRATION RULES. THIS CHILD HAS BEEN IN THIS COUNTRY FOR MANY YEARS AND IS WELL SETTLED INTO SCHOOL WHERE SHE HAS MADE FRIENDS AND IS DOING WELL. THE THREAT OF DEPORTATION HAS HOWEVER AFFECTED HER VERY BADLY PSYCHOLOGICALLY AND SHE HAS TAKEN TO SELF HARM.
    IT IS VERY DIFFICULT TO SEE WHAT IMPORTANT POINT OF PRINCIPLE IS SERVED BY INSISTING ON THE STRICT LETTER OF THE LAW IN THIS CASE WHEN A DISCRETIONARY ACT OF HUMANITY WOULD REBOUND FAR MORE TO THE CREDIT OF HM GOVERNMENT
    THE HOME SECRETARY’S ACTION IS QUITE DISPROPORTIONATE WHEN THERE ARE MANY CASES WHERE PEOPLE WHOSE PRESENCES IN THIS COUNTRY POSE A GENUINE THREAT TO PUBLIC ORDER AND COMMUNITY COHESION ARE PERMITTED TO CONTINUE REMAIN HERE
    I STRONGLY URGE YOU TO RECONSIDER YOUR PROPOSAL TO DEPORT THIS ENTIRELY BLAMELESS AND DECENT YOUNG GIRL.
    ALEXANDRA MACRAE
    DIRECTOR
    RACE EQUALITY COUNCIL FOR GLOUCESTERSHIRE

  • shuck // November 21, 2007 at 7:50 pm | Reply

    I blame this little girls parents for the current predicament. They knew that they had no right to be in this country as failed asulum seekers and would have been left in no doubt that if they failed to leave of their own accord they faced the humiliation of being forcibly removed.

    At the end of the day, the law of the UK says they must go. It may seem hard but we must all obey the law.

  • Susan Topping // November 22, 2007 at 10:31 am | Reply

    Mr Brown, could you please look into the case of Meltem Avcil and her mother. As a concerned member of the British public I have been following their story. The trauma this young girl and her mother are facing will stay with them for the rest of their lives. Give them a chance let Meltem grow up and be educated in this country. They have been in the country for 6 years, causing no problems, leading a peaceful happy life. To send them back would be cruel. And unjust.

  • iona liddell // November 22, 2007 at 10:32 am | Reply

    Dear Prime Minister,
    I am writing with regard to the case of Meltem Avcil and her mother – Kurdish asylum seekers who have made a life for themselves over the past 6 years in the UK. The manner in which that life has been intervened in (by the government) so abruptly, and apparently without concern for either Meltem or her mother’s social, physical or psychological wellbeing, disturbs me greatly.
    As leaders of the government on behalf of whom this action has been taken, I am urging you to reassess the situation and allow Meltem and her mother time to recover from the potentially enormous psychological trauma endured during their detention and attempted deportation. They are due for imminent deportation and I wholeheartedly believe this is not the right course of action for the present, and should be stopped. More than this, I ask that you make provisions to reassess their entire situation, given that Meltem Avcil has grown up in the UK during her formative years and such treatment as she and her mother have received lately undermines the very concept of refuge and humanitarian principles which we pertain to espouse and enshrine as a country.
    I would be very pleased to hear from you on this matter,
    Yours with concern,
    Iona Liddell
    LONDON

  • Alistair Cairns // November 22, 2007 at 10:33 am | Reply

    Dear Prime Minister,
    I urge you to act in the quickest and most deliberate manner possible to intervene to halt the removal of Meltem Avcil from the UK.
    I trust you will be aware of her, and her mother Cennet’s, circumstances and case as Kurdish refugees, as well as Meltem’s lengthy detainment at the Yarl’s Wood detention centre.
    I assume you will also know that today is Meltem’s 13th birthday. I hope you will find it in your conscience to stop her removal from the UK.
    We are watching to see how you act in this important case.
    Sincerely,
    Alistair Cairns
    EDINBURGH

  • David Pritchard // November 22, 2007 at 10:34 am | Reply

    Dear Mr Brown,
    I am writing to express my concern about the handling of the deportation case of Ms Meltem Avcil, recently publicised by the charity Positive Action in Housing, by Ms Dianne Abbott MP, by the Children’s Commissioner and by the Independent newspaper. There appears to be evidence to believe that this case is being handled without due respect for the rights of Ms Avcil and her mother, and the Home Office’s behaviour makes it appear that they are keen to deport these two women, by force if necessary, before the matters raised by their supporters can be properly attended to.
    You have spoken in the past about the central part which a respect for justice and human rights plays in Britain’s values and identity. The forcible removal of a child from Britain, at a time when there are still questions as to the treatment of this child by the Home Office and their private contractors, shows little evidence of this respect. I urge you to ensure that no deportation is carried out until the questions regarding Ms Avcil’s treatment have been answered and the concerns of Ms Avcil’s supporters addressed. I appreciate that not every asylum seeker is genuine and that justice must be carried out fairly; but justice is not the same as brutality, and a strong democratic society can surely afford to behave with care and forbearance when the welfare of a child is concerned.
    I urge you to ensure that in this case and in others the best values of our society are maintained.
    Yours sincerely,
    Dr David Pritchard
    GLASGOW

  • Mike Cowley // November 22, 2007 at 10:36 am | Reply

    Dear Gordon, having received this information regarding Meltem Avcil and his family, and as a Labour Party member of over 20 years standing, I again find myself asking what exactly it is that separates your administration – never mind the one we have just seen passing – from the Opposition. On such a rudimentary human issue like this, where the values you have warmed to in recent speeches are so egregiously trampled over, I am ashamed to widely advertise my activism in Leith Labour Party. What makes this more demoralising for me and others is the suspicion that this sort of coercive removal is carried out inn large part to appease the basest of public appetites invoked to a great extent by a media who have nothing but contempt for our Party and movement. I and others are expressing a simple human solidarity with Meltem and his family. I wonder if anyone in the Government is still capable of doing the same. Yours, Mike Cowley, Leith Labour Party.

  • Ewan Aitken // November 22, 2007 at 10:38 am | Reply

    Gordon
    Please read this and then ask yourself if this is the actions of a country you are proud to be Prime Minister of. Please stop this deportation. This wee girl will be killed if she is sent back. Whatever the technicalities, this cannot be right.

    please act

    yours

    Cllr Rev Ewan Aitken
    Leader, Labour Group
    City of Edinburgh Council

  • Howard Moss // November 22, 2007 at 10:58 am | Reply

    Dear Prime Minister,
    I understand that government authorization has been granted to Home Office officials to charter a private jet to remove 14 year old Hall Cross Lower pupil, Meltem Avcil, and her mother, either today or first thing tomorrow. We have been informed that removal is imminent and “use of force” has been authorized.
    Meltem Avcil, whose 14th birthday is today, had been assessed by doctors from Medical Justice yesterday. There was concern about Meltem’s psychological state, as a result of being incarcerated for three months at Yarlswood Detention Centre, after being dawn raided by an immigration snatch squad at their flat in Doncaster, their home for the past six years. Doctors requested she be transferred to Bedford Hospital for assessment.
    We believed she had been transferred to Bedford hospital along with her mother. Unfortunately this now seems not to be the case.
    What is most worrying of all is that the Children’s Commissioner has taken up Meltem’s case and Dianne Abbott MP raised her case in the House of Commons yesterday. Meltem’s case was also highlighted in today’s Independent newspaper.
    Meltem’s mobile phone has been cut off. During her time at Yarls Wood she says she was denied access to newspaper coverage of her case. The Home Office has cut off all communication with Meltem’s lawyers, despite counsel standing by to carry out a judicial review of her case.
    It seems absolutely extraordinary that all this expense and trouble should be gone to with the use of taxpayers’ money to effectivel;y terrorise a young girl and her mother and literally put them in fear of their lives, when at the very least a review of their case should take place.
    I would entreat you to use your good offices to intervene and make sure that this girl and her mother are accorded humane treatment and granted continued hospitality in this country while their situation is fairly considered.
    Yours sincerely,
    Howard Moss
    SWANSEA

  • Pam Cram // November 22, 2007 at 10:58 am | Reply

    I’m really concerned about reports I’m hearing of this young girl being deported, in spite of psychological reports which express concerns about her health, and action by the Childrens’ Commissioner on her behalf. It is shameful that a young girl should be held at Yarl’s Wood, and then sent to possible danger. Whatever the facts of the case I feel she should be kept here, preferably with her mother, and further enquiries made as regards her health and her future in her own country.
    REv. Pamela Cram, Swansea

  • Karen Palmer // November 22, 2007 at 10:59 am | Reply

    Dear Mrs Smith
    I am writing to ask you to halt the planned removal from UK of this girl (whose 14th birthday is today) and her mother. Please could they receive proper care and attention, considering all that they have been through in the last few months. Stories like those of Meltem Avcil and the way she has been treated by the authorities make me thoroughly ashamed to be British
    Yours sincerely
    (Dr) Karen Palmer

  • Jeff Alderson // November 22, 2007 at 11:22 am | Reply

    Dear Prime Minister,

    I am writing to you as one who has worked overseas for more than 30 years in the fields of development assistance and social justice. Accordingly I am well acquainted with the local circumstances.

    Subsequently in more recent years I am closely involved with support for asylum seekers, initially as a monitor with IMB and presently with a voluntary agency.

    I am therefore greatly disturbed at the actions being taken by the immigration officials in the case of Meltem Avcil who has just turned 14 years old and of her mother to deport them to Germany. From there, they will almost certainly be transferred on to Turkey where the mother’s life is likely to be under threat.

    You will already be aware from others of the details of this distressing case. Especially as it concerns Meltem, who has lived here for many years, is fluent in English, and has spent her schooling in the British system where she has obtained first class reports from her head and other teachers. Her friends are all local British girls.

    In addition the way in which both of them have been treated in recent months is deeply regrettable , both at Yarl Wood detention centre where they have been held for a long time, and then the manner of their attempted removal last week. To say the least, they would appear to have a good case for abuse of human rights.

    I understand that the Children’s Commissioner and Dianne Abbott MP are actively taking up their case. You will know that the national press has covered the issue again today.

    I call on you to use your good offices and authority to ensure that steps are made to ensure the endeavour to secure their removal from this country for the second time are halted with immediate and permanent effect. Further I would call on your personal sense of fairness and justice, which you have so often publicly referred to since becoming Prime Minister, including the debt you owe to your father as a Methodist minister, to make the necessary steps in line with this stance. I take the liberty of mentioned the latter, being myself involved in several prevailing issues in our parish through to the Diocese, including as chair of Diocesan World Development Group.

    I look forward to receiving your assurance and action as above. Thank you.

    I remain, yours respectfully,

    Jeff Alderson – Iffley, Oxford

  • Pamela S Adam // November 22, 2007 at 11:23 am | Reply

    Dear Mr Brown and Home Office

    I am writing to protest the removal, by force if required, of the above child. This act is barbaric and not too far off the snatches of Jews done by the SS in Nazi Germany. This is not a matter of security it’s a crime against a child and her family who thought this was a safe place.
    May I remind you of the children’s charter where it states states that governments should protect children from all forms of physical or mental violence. Your administration seem to think they are above this and can commit child abuse at will.

    Please take action to stop this act of violence on this child and her family.

    Yours Sincerely

    Pamela S Adam

  • Chris Hampton // November 22, 2007 at 11:27 am | Reply

    There is a law of common humanity that transcends your law. As a son of the manse, you should hold your head in shame at the treatment of a 14 year old. Her only crime is to have been brought to this country when she was about 8 years old. She has commited no offence. Let her stay, please! Thank you! Chris Hampton.

  • Odile Prud'hon // November 22, 2007 at 11:32 am | Reply

    Dear Sir,

    I urge you not to allow that Meltem Avcil and her mother to be expelled.
    Please reconsider their asylum request.
    Please show humanity: yesterday was the International Day for the Protection of Children.
    Nobody should be treated the way Meltem Avcil and her mother were on a past attempt to expell them.

    Yours respectfully,

    Odile Prud’hon
    France

  • Dr Simon Yuill // November 22, 2007 at 11:35 am | Reply

    I am writing to protest against the deportation of 13 year old Doncaster schoolgirl Meltem Avcil and her mother Cennet who are currently incarcerated at Yarlswood Detention Centre, and due to be deported from the UK on Thursday 22nd November.

    Meltem has been living in Doncaster, England for the past six years, since 2001. Her schoolteachers at Hall Cross Lower School, Doncaster, describe her as a ‘No.1 student’. She speaks with an English accent, speaks perfect English, her dreams and aspirations are essentially English, and the only country she knows as her home in the true sense of the word is Doncaster, England where her friends, neighbours, school and community remains. Her 14th birthday is on November 21. For almost three months she and her mother have been in Yarlswood, and Meltem has recently begun self harming amid fears for her psychological wellbeing.

    Meltem and her mother, Cennet, fear removal to Germany, a country they have absolutely no connection with, and from there to Turkey, a country they fled in 2001 because they were persecuted as Kurds.

    The family has lived in the UK for over six years and have clear human rights grounds for them to remain in the UK under a family amnesty and to not be removed to Germany:

    * Meltem Avcil is 13 years old and about to turn 14 on November 21st 2007.
    * She has been in school in the UK for SIX years
    * Mrs Avcil and her daughter have NEVER absconded or disobeyed ANY UK immigration rules
    * Both mother and child have been detained like criminals for almost THREE months
    * She has had NO schooling since being incarcerated
    * Her mental and psychological state has deteriorated, from being a normal, healthy bubbly teenager to a scared, depressed, lonely young girl, turning to self harm (She began cutting herself a few days ago)
    * Their lawyer is still pursuing legal routes to help them remain in this country

    The facts of Meltem’s case are very similar to that of the AY family (who you may be familiar with), where the German government gave status to the family on humanitarian grounds, after psychiatric reports showed the children had been psychologically traumatised during their incarceration in the United Kingdom.

    I believe that the trauma that the UK government has put Melte Avcil through will haunt her for the rest of her life, and that it is in the best interests of this child to be returned to her home in Doncaster, the familiarity of her school, friends and teachers, and to have access within this comfort zone to psychiatrists to assist her in returning to her former happy self.

    Your sincerely,
    Dr Simon Yuill
    University of Dundee

  • mich dedet // November 22, 2007 at 11:42 am | Reply

    Pas d’expulsion demain pour la jeune MELTEM !

  • Lorraine Barrie // November 22, 2007 at 11:43 am | Reply

    Dear Sirs

    I am writing regarding Meltem Avcil, the 14 year old Hall Cross Lower pupil who is facinng deportation with her mother.

    Meltem is only a child and yet she has been detained in Yarlswood for 3 months. She is unwell and doctors have asked that she be transferred to Bedford hospital for assessment.

    I am writing to ask that Meltem and her mother are not deported and she recieves the medical assistance she requires. She is only a child and has attended school here. Diane Abbot has raised this matter in the Commons and I would appeal to you to intervene and stop this deportation for the sake of Meltem’s health.

    I look forward to recieving your comments. Thank you for your kind attention.

    Yours,

    Lorraine Barrie
    Solicitor

  • Jean MacKenzie // November 22, 2007 at 11:44 am | Reply

    Dear Mr Brown and Ms Smith
    I was very concerned to read today’s Independent article about the treatment of Meltem Avcil and her mother. While I have enormous respect for both of you, and wish you very well in this administration, I am appalled to think that my government can feel justified in expelling asylum seekers in such a brutal manner.

    As a secondary school teacher and a mother of two daughters I can just imagine how traumatic this whole process must be for Meltem and her mother. However shaky their case for asylum is, I strongly believe that Meltem should be allowed to complete her education at ‘home’ in Doncaster as this upheaval can only be very harmful to her. What chance will she have of a settled future in Turkey when she and her mother seem to be so scared of going there?

    I understand that a private aeroplane might be chartered to take Meltem and her mother way by force, in secret, to avoid distressing other passengers – this looks very underhand to me and I do not want feel that a government that I respect is capable of such conduct.

    Please think again about this case. A young person who has spent five years in this country and has settled well at school should surely be allowed to complete her education here. Surely that is what you would wish for your own children, if they had not been lucky enough to be born here?

    Your sincerely
    Jean MacKenzie
    GLASGOW

  • Terence McGeary // November 22, 2007 at 11:44 am | Reply

    Dear Prime Minister,

    To get to the point straightaway I must ask if you find the treatment given to the Avcil family at all appropriate?

    As a college lecturer here in Scotland I know that some of my overseas students have endured a lot to get here: a lot of hardship, a lot of indignity and a lot of uncertainty.

    Perhaps in some cases the UK has been taken advantage of by individuals with no strong case for being here apart from wishing to improve their comfort level compared to their native country. I have no wish to support that when the DFID can do a better job at the root.

    Others however have chosen to escape the horrors of their homeland. This group surely deserves the humanitarian support that the UK can be charitable enough to afford them.

    In addition to this when there are children involved it adds a complicating factor to the equation: there are situations where it may be tempting to take an easy route and solve the problem by bundling people onto a private plane and (rather like disposal of rubbish) forgetting about them. This cannot surely be the right thing to do with children and their parents? Or perhaps it is the humanitarian way to solve the problem?
    I would be happy to receive your views on this, preferably before the next ‘refuse’ collection.

    Regards,
    Terence McGeary
    East Kilbride

  • Guy Whitmarsh // November 22, 2007 at 11:45 am | Reply

    I hear that 14 year old ( birthday today ) Meltem and her mother are due to be deported to Germany today by charter flight. They have been in this country for 6 years, nearly half Meltem’s life. Is it not passing the buck to send them to Germany, leaving German authorities with the difficult decision?
    Even disregarding the rights and wrongs of their asylum case, can we not show just a little compassion for two people whose lives have already been blighted?
    I urge you to cancel their deportation and to give them leave to remain in the UK.
    Guy Whitmarsh

  • Marilyn Thomas // November 22, 2007 at 11:46 am | Reply

    Dear Gordon Brown,

    I have heard news today that Meltem and Cennet Avcil are in imminent danger of deportation. Meltem is a 14 year old brought up in this country.
    We have already written to the Home Secretary about their case and are now making a direct appeal to you. We have attached a letter to her which has specific details of their case. Last week the Government attempted to deport Meltem and her mother. They were so distressed that they resisted the security guards, and the pilot had to refuse to carry them on the plane. I have included Meltem’s own account below, and find it very disturbing.
    We do not know Meltem and her mother personally, but have been following their case with increasing concern over the last few weeks. The Children’s Commissioner is concerned about their case. We think that you should be too.
    We are asking for their release and for a sympathetic consideration of their case.
    While we are writing to you we need to make some more general points about government asylum policy. We are deeply distressed by the imprisonment of innocent children and young people by our government. We can vouch personally for the terrible fear that many of our asylum seeking friends here in Swansea have experienced during periods of detention in Yarlswood.. One friend of ours was driven to the airport with her small son and was willing to undergo any mistreatment rather then be returned to the rape and torture she had experienced in Uganda. The morning of her threatened removal she was vomiting with fear. She is now back in Swansea but her normally equable and happy 10 year old is having serious and frequent nightmares. Local support for asylum seekers is growing here, with regular supportive stories in the local press and neighbours rallying round law abiding people who have a contribution to make to our city and the country generally.
    We are concerned that many of the people facing deportation have not had fair legal representation. Asylum seekers are not able to afford decent legal representation and increasingly restrictive policies on the amount of legal aid granted to asylum seekers.

    I have been canvassing for the Labour Party since the age of 10. I am no longer able to offer any active support, and were it not for the pro-asylum views of our local MP, Martin Caton, I would not be able in all conscience to vote Labour again. We support your compassion for the poverty which experience in Africa. We find it hypocritical however when contrasted by the injustice and brutality with which your government is treating asylum seekers. These are often the people who are opposing brutal regimes. They deserve better.
    Yours sincerely
    Marilyn Thomas

  • Jo Haythornthwaite // November 22, 2007 at 11:50 am | Reply

    Dear Gordon
    You will not remember me but I was Depute College Librarian at Glasgow College when you taught politics there for a year while nursing a constituency. You were always very busy and rushed in and out of the Library! We all knew you had a great future ahead of you and believed your “son of the Manse” background would ensure high principles and a caring attitude.
    It is to that caring attitude that I wish to appeal.
    This little girl is 14 today and faces removal back to Turkey in the next few days. Turkey still discriminates against Kurds, her Father has disappeared and the future that awaits her and her Mother would be grim. Meltem is a clever girl who would like to study medicine and could be an asset to this country.
    An article in the Independent yesterday is a cause of great concern in that it describes the rough and inhumane treatment meted out to this child and her Mother in the course of a previous attemt to force them on to a plane. I do not like to think that such treatment is meted out to defenceless woman and children in this country.
    Possibly Meltem and her Mother could be reconsidered as legacy cases?
    Please give this matter some thought and discuss it with the Home Secretary. We are a rich enough country (thanks to your prudent management of the economy) to be able to show some compassion.

    Yours sincerely
    Jo Haythornthwaite
    Previously University Librarian Glasgow Caledonian University

  • Megan McFarlane // November 22, 2007 at 12:04 pm | Reply

    Dear Mr Brown and Ms Smith,

    I am writing to protest about the treatment of MELTEM AVCIL and her mother and their imminent deportation. It seems that the treatment of Meltem and her Mum over the past months, with their detention at Yarls Court (and attempted deportation) is a horrific abuse of their human rights.
    It is disgusting that “use of force” has been authorised, especially against a 14 year old.
    I find the details of the case distressing and I urge you to cancel this deportation.

    Yours sincerely,
    Megan McFarlane

  • Bob Doris MSP // November 22, 2007 at 12:05 pm | Reply

    Dear Mr Brown and Ms Smith,

    The case of Meltem Avcil has been brought to my attention and I have been asked to contact yourselves with regards this matter. I appreciate that MSP’s do represent constituents in England but I would still be keen to have this situation clarified. Can you please give me an update as soon as possible on what is happening to Meltem and confirm if Meltem has been denied access to her lawyers, and if any attempted removal of Meltem and her mother may have thwarted the attempts of their lawyers to carry out a judicial review, and indeed the attempts of the Children’s Commissioner to look at Meltem’s situation. Wouldn’t this call into question their right to due process under the law? Can you also clarify the treatment of Meltem and her mother with regards the abortive forced removal which sounds very distressing for both ladies.

    Yours sincerely,

    Bob Doris MSP

  • Reuben Anderson // November 22, 2007 at 12:06 pm | Reply

    Sir,

    I would like to express my objection to what I understand to be the forced removal Meltem Avcil and her mother from Britain.

    I fundamentally object to the use of private security firms acting at the direction of the state. In my opinion this cannot avoid incidents of failure to meet the state’s duty to protect the human rights of those people within the nations borders. The objectives of a private company are incompatible with public service, and cannot but lead to injustice.

    I believe the United Kingdom should act, and be seen to act on the international stage, in a manner that is, lenient, tolerant and generous toward assylum seekers, rejecting only those with violent intentions toward this state and it’s people.

    Regards,
    Reuben Anderson

  • Philippa Vafadari // November 22, 2007 at 12:08 pm | Reply

    Dear Mr Brown
    I want to object to the deportation of Meltem Avcil and to their detention in Yarlswood. The treatment of this family and 1,000’s of others like them is inhumane and not worthy of a so-called ‘civilized’ country such as Britain. They are not criminals. They are fleeing persecution from countries whose problems often stem from the past and present actions of Britain. We should accept that our actions in these countries create refugees and it is Britain’s duty to look after these people.
    Yours sincerely
    Philippa Vafadari

  • Marie Payre // November 22, 2007 at 12:09 pm | Reply

    To the Prime Minister and members of the UK government

    Please, let Meltem Avcil (14 years old) and her mother come back freely in their home, in Doncaster.

    Marie Payre

Leave a Comment